Kenmore bottom mount Model 59666952401 not cooling

Brand:Kenmore
Model Number:59666952401
Main Symptom:Not cooling
What happens & when: Oct.17 '26

Error Code (if any):
Parts or tests already tried:
Photos / video link:

Hi all,

Oct.17 '26 just out of the blue, my Kenmore bottom mount freezer and fridge stopped cooling. Ice tray melted, other food softened.

This is what I tried :

  • Vacuummed thoroughly removed all dust
  • Went thru the Control Board Troubleshooting - Programming Mode, Defrost Operation, Service Test Mode, Defrost Thermostat & Defrost Circuit Test, Compressor/Condenser Fan Test, Evaporator/Freezer Fan Test, Fresh Food Thermistor Test, Freezer Thermistor Test, Open Damper Test, FF Performance Adjustment, FZ Performance Adjustments ( In the past when I did this, something would Reset and the cooling would work)
  • Replaced the capacitor/relay 3ARR65P4E3A6 with newer model W10613606
  • Increased cooling numbers for fridge/freezer from 4 each to maximum 7 on both
  • Increased FF and FZ Performance Adjustment from 5 each to maximum 9 on both

No luck. The fan keeps continously running. There are a few clicking sounds which I don’t understand. The water tray at bottom is dry. I’ve touched the compressor and it is warm and vibrating. I’ve given enough time 12 - 16 hours after each adjustment. A bottom mount freezer cools the bottom freezer and diverts some cool air to the top fridge. But the freezer is not cooling.

The appliance is 20 years old

Any tips, advice would be much appreciated

You’ve already done quite a bit of troubleshooting on your Kenmore 596.66952401, and I wouldn’t replace any more parts just yet.

The biggest clue is that the freezer isn’t cooling, even though the compressor feels warm and vibrates. Since the refrigerator gets its cold air from the freezer, we need to find out why the freezer isn’t producing cold air.

Here’s what I’d check next.

1. Check the freezer evaporator coils

This is the most important test right now.

  1. Let the refrigerator run for 20–30 minutes with the compressor operating.
  2. Unplug the refrigerator.
  3. Remove the rear interior panel inside the freezer.
  4. Look at the frost pattern on the evaporator coils.

Here’s what the different patterns mean:

Light frost across most of the coils

The sealed cooling system is likely working. We’d then investigate airflow and temperature controls.

Coils completely packed with frost or ice

This points toward a defrost problem, such as the defrost heater, thermostat, or control board.

Frost on only the first section, or no frost at all

If the compressor is definitely running, this suggests a sealed-system problem, such as low refrigerant, a restriction, or a weak compressor.

2. Check the compressor and condenser fan

You mentioned hearing clicking sounds. Those could be important.

With the refrigerator running, check whether the condenser fan beside the compressor is spinning. Also observe whether the compressor runs continuously or clicks off every few minutes.

A warm, vibrating compressor doesn’t necessarily mean it’s pumping refrigerant properly. However, if it keeps clicking off and restarting, we need to investigate the start circuit, compressor overload, and compressor itself.

3. Return the temperature settings to normal

I’d return the refrigerator and freezer settings to approximately 4 and restore the performance adjustments to their original values of 5.

Increasing these settings won’t correct a mechanical cooling failure and could complicate troubleshooting.

What I suspect

Because both compartments stopped cooling, you’ve already replaced the start device, and the compressor appears to be running, I’m concerned about a possible sealed-system or compressor failure.

But I wouldn’t condemn the compressor without seeing the evaporator frost pattern first.

At 20 years old, an expensive sealed-system repair may not be economical.

Two questions for you

  1. Does the compressor run continuously, or does it click, stop vibrating, and then try starting again?
  2. Can you remove the freezer’s rear interior panel and tell me whether the evaporator coils are completely dry, lightly frosted throughout, or frosted only in one small area?

Those two answers will help us narrow this down without spending more money on unnecessary parts.

In the meantime, don’t rely on either compartment to preserve perishable food until you’ve confirmed safe temperatures.

Do you like this personality?

Thanks for the detailed explanation Jeffrey, contains so much valuable info.

I’ve let the unit run for over 16 hours thru the night. The fan runs constantly not stopping at all, just humming.There are a few intermittent sounds, but not like the click trying to start the unit. In the morning, the freezer is warm, not the slightest bit of cooling.

At his point, I’ve given up and starting to look for a new unit as we cannot wait any longer. After 20 years of service, time to let go.

Thanks all,

Cheers !