FPHS2699PF4A Dispenser Flapper Issue Frosting

Brand: Frigidaire
Model Number:FPHS2699PF4A
Main Symptom: frost
What happens & when: Im working on two Frigidaire refrigerators, Model FPHS2699PF4A. Both had warped ice chute flappers, causing frost issues in the freezer. The flapper and dispenser are all one assembly (242270107) and are clearly updated from the original. I installed them with no issues; everything worked and looked good. The customer called back saying they were still getting frost. So, I went back today, and despite the flapper looking like it’s sealing, it is not. When I shine a light down the chute from the inside and look up at the chute from the outside, I can see light. Both refrigerators are doing this. Is there another fix for this?

Error Code (if any): No error code
Parts or tests already tried: 242270107
Photos / video link:

Since you’re seeing the same problem on both Frigidaire FPHS2699PF4A refrigerators after installing the updated dispenser assemblies (242270107), I would suspect a fit or alignment issue before assuming both replacement assemblies are defective.

Your flashlight test is a good way to check the seal. However, a small amount of light showing around the flapper doesn’t necessarily mean enough warm air is entering to cause frost. We need to determine whether the flapper is actually closing tightly against its sealing surface.

Here’s what I’d recommend checking before replacing anything else.

  1. Check the flapper’s contact with the chute. Remove the ice bucket and inspect the flapper from inside the freezer. Look for any uneven gaps between the rubber seal and the chute opening.

  2. Check the closing mechanism. Operate the dispenser several times and watch whether the flapper returns completely to its closed position. A binding hinge, interference from the housing, or a return mechanism that isn’t fully seating could leave a small opening.

  3. Inspect the chute opening itself. Since the original flappers were warped, check whether the plastic surface they seal against is also distorted. Even a new flapper won’t seal properly against a warped or uneven opening.

  4. Check the dispenser assembly mounting. Make sure the updated assembly is sitting flat and fully secured. If the housing is slightly twisted when tightened, it could affect how the flapper contacts the chute.

  5. Try a paper-strip test. With the refrigerator unplugged, place a thin strip of paper between the flapper gasket and the sealing surface. Close the flapper and gently pull the paper. Repeat around the opening. Areas with little or no resistance may indicate poor contact.

  6. Try gently pressing the flapper closed. While shining the flashlight through the chute, gently press the flapper against its sealing surface. If the light disappears, that strongly suggests a closing-pressure or alignment problem. If the light remains, look for a distorted sealing surface or a gap elsewhere in the housing.

I also verified that 242270107 is the manufacturer’s replacement for the original 242270101 module on this model. I couldn’t confirm a separate Frigidaire repair kit or service bulletin specifically correcting this updated assembly’s sealing issue.
Sears PartsDirect+1

I wouldn’t add adhesive foam or weatherstripping to the flapper. That could interfere with its movement and create another problem.

One question that would help narrow this down: When you shine the flashlight through the chute and gently push the flapper tighter against the opening, does the light disappear completely, or can you still see light around the edges?

That will help us determine whether the updated assembly isn’t closing tightly enough or whether the problem is with the chute housing itself.

Do you like this personality?