Infinity switch for Jenn air jes9750aab, new switch does not fit my stove

Oven/Range/Cooktop Repair
1

Brand: Jenn Air
Model Number: jes9750aab
Main Symptom: Recommended Replacement Switch does not match the one in my oven
What happens & when: The old replacement switch has 5 terminals sticking out of the back of the switch. The new/replacement switch w11120791, has the terminals “down on the side”. However, when I replaced the switch, the wiring arched and threw the breaker (because the terminals on the side are too close, for the wiring on this oven). Looks like I need to find a switch with the five terminals sticking out the back that works for this stove jes9750aab?

Error Code (if any):
Parts or tests already tried:
Photos / video link:

2

It sounds like the switch was wired incorrectly. Connect the L1 to the top terminal on the right side where it says L1 and the L2 will go to the bottom terminal. This is a common thing where it looks like they are right next to each other but would have a terminal between them.