I appreciate the continued advice. I tried switching the wires, but the connector won't fit on the ice maker inlet valve prongs, I think they idiot proofed them by making one smaller and one larger.

I took the freezer wire off and am not detecting any voltage to the wires. How can I check for voltage on the freezer wire though, I'm assuming it only gets voltage when the ice maker calls for water. Is there a way to force the ice maker to call for water so I can check to see if it's getting voltage?