Hello WCD. It sounds like you may have a bad compressor on this one. If you replaced the starter and the unit worked, then as the pressure built, on restart, clicking returns, then the compressor is bad on the unit. Hope this helps.
Thanks for allowing AppliancePartsPros.com to assist you,
Jeff K. / APP TEAM
Find Appliance Parts at AppliancePartsPros.com - Largest inventory in the U.S. with 91% of all in-stock orders delivered within 2 business days. Thousands of photos and diagrams make it very easy to find the right part. Enter your appliance model here.